The Least, First

Monte Asbury's blog

Alfred Lilienthal, 1949: Israel’s Flag is Not Mine

with 13 comments

How very intriguing it is to read the early Jewish anti-Zionists! Lilienthal, an American, articulately decried the way his lifelong faith became a tool of Israeli nationalism, and used as a competitor intended to weaken his American identity.  [H/T Servant Savant!]

By Alfred M. Lilienthal

Dear Mother:

I brought you my hurts and troubles when both they and I were little: in that same spirit I bring them to you today.

Image by templar1307 via Flickr

Only last year, a new white flag with single blue six-pointed star was hoisted to a mast many thousands of miles away on the east coast of the Mediterranean Sea. This flag of Israel is the symbol of a new nationalist state, with its own government, army, foreign policy, language, national anthem and oath of allegiance.

And this new flag has brought every one of us five million American citizens of the ancient faith of Judah to a parting in the road.

Judaism, I have felt, was a religious faith which knew no national boundaries, to which a loyal citizen of any country could adhere.

By contrast, Zionism was and is a nationalist movement organized to reconstitute Jews as a nation with a separate homeland. Now that such a state exists, what am I? Am I still only an American who believes in Judaism? Or am I-as extreme Zionists and anti-Semites alike argue-a backsliding member of an Oriental tribe whose loyalty belongs to that group?

Heroes of Israel

Image by templar1307 via Flickr

Let us start, Mother, with how I feel about this new State of Israel. I wish it well. I hope that several hundred thousand suffering displaced persons will find in it a happy home. I hope it will prosper as a center of democracy in the Middle East. But when its flag was first raised on May 14, 1948, I had no impulse to dance in the street with hysterical joy, as did so many in New York and London. ForI was born and remain an American. I have no ties with, no longings for, and feel no responsibilities to Israel. And I believe that the future happiness of the Jews in America depends on their complete integration as citizens of this-our true-country.

I am sure that if we Jews as a group are persuaded to divide that love which people normally give to their native land, it can lead only to disaster.

The Irish? They are a nation and Judaism is a religion. Irishmen here have left Ireland only in recent generations. The Jews left Palestine in Roman times, and have come here from every European country.

Jewish New Year Parade - N.Y., 1912 (LOC)
Image by The Library of Congress via Flickr

My one and only homeland is America. I am proud of my belief in the age-old Judaic concept of one God in Heaven and one Humanity here below. But my faith does not pull me into a feeling of narrowly tribal kinship with all others who worship God in this way. Whenever I read of Americans singing the Hatikvah, Israel’s national anthem, or see youth groups raising Israel’s flag beside the Stars and Stripes. I am outraged. For Israel’s flag and anthem are symbols of a foreign state; ,they are not mine.

The most powerful weapon which Zionism is using on Americans of Jewish faith is its outward cloak of humanitarianism. The argument runs that Israel was set up primarily as a haven for the persecuted, the homeless, so why should we be critical?

Chaim Weizmann
Image via Wikipedia

Mother, the truth is that Israel was not created primarily for displaced persons. Instead, Article 3 of its proposed constitution proclaims it to be “the national home of the Jewish people.” Meaning, Mother, you and me! As early as 1917 Dr. Chaim Weizmann, Israel’s first president, was proclaiming: “We have never based the Zionist Movement on Jewish suffering in Russia or any other land. These sufferings have never been the mainspring of Zionism.”

Rabbi Abba H. Silver, a recent head of the American Zionists, declared: “We must stand foursquare on the proposition that Zionism is not an immigration or a refugee movement, but a movement to rebuild the Jewish State for the Jewish nation in the land of Israel.”

And what is the attitude of Israel toward those who adhere to the faith of Judaism but are citizens of other countries? Our “nationality” they insist is Jewish, no matter under what flags we were born; and, since we are not in Israel, we live “in the Diaspora,” which is to say in exile. And their plans for us?

“We must,” explained Prime Minister Ben-Gurion, in his first speech after the Israeli elections, “save the remnants of Israel in the Diaspora. We must also save their possessions. Without these two things, we shall not build this country.”

So the vast Zionist propaganda machine strives to cement national ties between Israel and all persons of Jewish faith. And sending money to Israel is only a small part of our supposed obligation. The deeper objectives are given by Dr. Margoshes, an executive of the American Section of the Jewish Agency, as being:
” – to Zionize world Jewry. . .to establish Zionist hegemony over the developing Jewish communities throughout the world.”

Jews Against zionism
Image by helen.2006 via Flickr

Daniel Frisch, newly elected president of the American Zionists, feels that “the American Jewish community will soon arrive at the inevitable conclusion that the all-day school plus a chain of summer camps is the only solution to the problem,” and that “we ought to be able to send to Israel American-bred young people who want to live as Jews minus the hyphen under the smiling skies of the reborn Israel. Our task has not ended with the birth of the Jewish State. It has but begun.”

Have these misguided zealots forgotten the indignation which was aroused in America In the ’30’s, when the Bundists tried to tell Americans of German ancestry that they owed loyalty to Germany, and set up in America youth camps dedicated to German culture?

Today we see Zionists boasting of “Jewish” political strength, Zionist picket lines around British consulates, Zionists demonstrating against Foreign Minister Ernest Bevin when he arrives here to sign the Atlantic Pact, New York stores plastered with posters screaming “Do Not Buy British. Made Goods.”

Are these people acting as Americans? Europe’s recovery through the Marshall Plan is the keystone of our bipartisan foreign policy, which the Communists are trying to sabotage. Any boycott of British goods, organized or unorganized, helps this destruction. Now I know these Zionists were not consciously trying to tear down American foreign policy, but their actions were the inevitable result of living under segregation is not solely the fault of the other guy. Part of the responsibility is on our shoulders. True, the Jew is sometimes segregated by Christians. But it is also true that the Jew sometimes sets himself apart from Christians.

We have moved out of the ghetto, but sometimes scars of the long imprisonment remain. This is why many Jews even today feel at home only with other Jews. Many carry their Jewishness on their sleeves and are extremely self-conscious and sensitive to their separateness.

ALL OF THIS I understand: most of it I forgive. After all, six million Jews were wiped out by Hitler and anti-Semitism does exist, even in America. Why should each of us not be at least a little sensitive? This I think most non-Jews understand. But when anyone criticizes, however mildly, either Zionism, the State of Israel or the hysterical behavior of some groups of Jews, we have no right to shout “anti-Semitism!”

In any religion one can find a small group of fanatics who hate those of other faiths. Such fanatics are not numerous or important. It is Semitism-the constant effort of some Jews to assert themselves as Jews-and not their religion of Judaism which feeds anti-Semitism.

‘No one knows better than you, Mother, that I, too. suffered humiliation from being a Jew. I have felt the arrows of discrimination. In my deep hurt I have cried out. But the discipline of two nationalisms. Were Hitler alive today, how he would laugh!

The plain fact is that we Jews are not a race and we should not let the Zionists persuade us that we are. Proof to the contrary lies in Palestine, plain for all to see. You had my letter, Mother, from my Army furlough there. I was second to none in my enthusiasm for what my co-religionists had done-for a desert brought to bloom, for clean new cities rising out of age-old sand dunes. All of these wonders had come to pass while only a few fanatics talked of statehood. One evening I went to see a performance ,of an opera in Jerusalem. In that theater lobby you could distinguish almost at a glance the Yiddish-speaking Ashkenazic Jew from Poland, the Spanish-speaking Sephardic Jew from North Africa or Turkey, the German Jew, Jews from a score of countries all differing in dress, language, manners and mental attitudes. I had visual proof of the arguments of anthropologists. who laugh at the notion of a distinct Jewish race.

A Yemenite Jew at morning prayers, wearing a k...
Image via Wikipedia

Anyone who tells me those foreign Jews are exclusively my people that I should be closer to them than to Bob McCormick, the kid on the block with whom I used to play ball: or to Nick Galbraith, who roomed next to me at Cornell; or Dave Du Vivier with whom I studied in law school-that man is talking dangerous nonsense. I have also learned, Mother, that when something. goes wrong in my relations with non-Jews. I avoid the habit of thinking that it happened just because I am a Jew. Such self-pity is comforting, but it is usually wrong and therefore dangerous.

There is today a deep split among Americans of the Jewish faith. The Zionists are the more vocal; they have more organized political power. But they do not speak for all of us, and I hope not for most. On the other side there is, for instance, the American Council for Judaism, which insists that the nationalism of Israel must be confined to the boundaries of that state. There are also countless other Jews without any affiliation who revere Judaism as a religion and scorn to degrade it into a cheap racial nationalism which competes with their Americanism.

But when we protest the right of the Zionists to speak as “American Jewry” on the question of Palestine, we are told that Jews should not be disunited, must not fight among themselves on Palestine or any other issue. And if we still speak out against what we feel is a dangerous trend, we find ourselves reviled and ostracized as traitors. Coercion, often economic, frequently silences the freethinker.

But why should Americans of Jewish faith be any more united on questions of American foreign policy than are Presbyterians, Baptists or Methodists?

Have we forgotten the words of Woodrow Wilson in 1915 when he warned all Americans: “You cannot become true Americans if you think of yourselves in groups. A man who thinks of himself as belonging to a particular national group in America has not yet become an American. And a man who goes among you to trade on your nationality is not worthy to live under the Stars and Stripes.”

Politicians of both parties who in the last election played to “the Jewish vote”‘ in connection with Israel will do well to reread those words.

Palestinian-Jewish Solidarity
Image by MatthewBradley via Flickr

The answer to bigotry and anti-Semitism does not lie in fanatical Jewish nationalism. Of course the blowing-up of the King David Hotel, the hanging of the two British sergeants, the assassination of Bernadotte, the massacre of Arab women and children at Dier Yasin were all acts of tiny groups. But they have weakened the moral and spiritual stature of the world’s oldest religion. Israel’s terrorist Beigin and Hollywood’s Ben Hecht, who encouraged such lawlessness by saying, “Every time you let go with your guns at the British betrayers of your homeland, the Jews of America make a little holiday in their hearts!” such people are doing the Jews more harm than any words which Goebbels spoke.

There was no holiday in my heart, nor in that of the late Rabbi J. L Magnes, president of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, who said sadly following that Hecht statement: “We had always thought that Zionism would diminish anti-Semitism in the world. We are witness to the opposite.”

All too many Christians have supported Zionism because they felt that Jews, having been persecuted, should now have what they want whether it is good or bad for them. Christian leaders can help us greatly. But Christian sympathy for Jews should be measured not in terms of support for Jewish nationalism in distant Israel but in accepting us as friends, neighbors and first-class citizens of this our country. That is true liberal Christianity. And also, Mother, good Judaism, that fine old faith which you taught me as a little child.

1949 The Reader’s Digest Association, Inc. Pleasantville New York
Reprinted from the September, 1949 issue of The Reader’s Digest.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

13 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. […] see support for Israel as divinely ordained. In 1949, however, when Lilienthal wrote “Israel’s Flag is Not Mine” for Readers Digest, his critique of Zionist propaganda was shared by mainstream conservatives […]

  2. […] Have you ever read Alfred Lillenthal? Alfred Lilienthal, 1949: Israel’s Flag is Not Mine…g-is-not-mine/ Reply With […]

  3. […] see support for Israel as divinely ordained. In 1949, however, when Lilienthal wrote “Israel’s Flag is Not Mine” for Readers Digest, his critique of Zionist propaganda was shared by mainstream conservatives […]

  4. […] who see support for Israel as divinely ordained. In 1949, however, when Lilienthal wrote “Israel’s Flag is Not Mine” for Readers Digest, his critique of Zionist propaganda was shared by mainstream […]

  5. […] who see support for Israel as divinely ordained. In 1949, however, when Lilienthal wrote “Israel’s Flag is Not Mine” for Readers Digest, his critique of Zionist propaganda was shared by mainstream conservatives as […]

  6. […] who see support for Israel as divinely ordained. In 1949, however, when Lilienthal wrote “Israel’s Flag is Not Mine” for Readers Digest, his critique of Zionist propaganda was shared by mainstream conservatives as […]

  7. Lilienthal was one of a few very great prophetic voices within American Judaism who saw the dangers of religious nationalism, and spoke out against Zionism.
    But I don’t think the real danger is dual loyalty. One can have multiple loyalties, if those loyalties proceed from a sound moral code or philosophy, and do not diverge too sharply from one loyalty to another.

    The problem is when one’s loyalties are divided between good and evil solutions to the world’s problems. The problem with Israel today is not simply that it wants to represent all the world’s Jews, but that it is becoming an apartheid state. Furthermore, it is rapidly moving in the direction of fascism.

    Religious nationalism is dangerous because it takes a people in only one direction–to the extreme political right, to Jewish fascism. So the real problem is that American Jews support, or tend to support, reasonably progressive domestic policies for the US, but horrific policies for Palestinians in Israel/Palestine.

    Sadly, the strain is so great, and the trauma of everything that has happened since the Holocaust so monumental, that American Zionists–and a fair number of American Jews under the influence of Zionists–have tended to simply blind themselves to what is happening by escaping in two ways.

    First is the full-tilt escape into intentional stupidity. “Don’t show me the pictures! Don’t confuse me with the facts!” People who can’t stand to hear criticism of Israel refuse to read the websites of the Israeli human rights organizations in the Holy State that they support so uncritically. If the Israeli state succeeds in suppressing those organizations, they’ll be the first to celebrate, I’m afraid, because then they can pretend they don’t see what’s happening to Palestinians.

    Secondly, American Zionists tend to escape into victim status, posturing themselves as pitiful victims rather than living like proud survivors. Only if American Jews become protagonists can they begin to deconstruct the systemic evil that Zionism has become, and probably was from the beginning. Whether they choose to do so is a separate issue. But first, one must stop with the victimology already, and start acting, feeling and thinking like survivors who do not need to apologize to anybody for being for or against any particular Israeli policy.

    My guess is that a majority of American Jews will eventually do that, at which time they will most likely see that post-Zionist solutions must be considered in Israel/Palestine, as well as the conventional Zionist ones. So the strategy of the Likudniks is simple: carry out the slow ethnic cleansing of Palestinians before the American Jewish community wakes up to what Zionism has really become.


    February 22, 2011 at 4:04 am

  8. FACT: The Torah says God”s Historic Deed To Israel was given to The Hebrews,
    FACT: The Torah says The Hebrews/Jews ill be dispersed and then be brought back to The Promised Land.
    FACT: The dispersed Jews were brought brought back to The Holy Land slowly, then as a Nation in 1948.
    FACT: The Torah calls Israel THE LIGHT UNTO THE NATIONS.
    OPINION: Some feel that Israel is not yet to be a Nation, since Moshiak did not arrive. Others declare it is the right time.
    FACT: While some disagree, they hold back respect and love of fellow Jews, indeed express hostility.
    FACT: Judaism requires polite, respectful indeed loving actions toward those we disagree with.

    Norman Hauptman

    July 27, 2010 at 4:38 pm

  9. Mr L was a true Jew.


    December 15, 2009 at 1:15 pm

    • The world needs more MEN like Mr. Lilienthal!


      May 10, 2010 at 6:02 pm

  10. Just dropping by.Btw, you website have great content!


    March 3, 2009 at 12:34 am

  11. This had explained a lot to me. I thank you for posting.

    Monte Says: Many thanks, friend! Your words help me!

    Rick Reiley

    March 2, 2009 at 6:50 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: