Bible vs. homosexuality? Handle with care!
UPDATE (June 4, 2009): The 40-some page paper from the late 1990’s by Nazarene scholar/theologial J. Kenneth Grider, which is mentioned in the comments after this post, is now available here: Wesleyans and Homosexuality by J. Kenneth Grider. Grider, who died in 2006, taught at Nazarene Theological Seminary for 38 years, served on the translation committe of the New International Version (NIV) of the Bible, and wrote the 1994 book A Wesleyan-Holiness Theology. Many thanks to Lin Wells, who gave me a copy of the paper.
Further, my nephew Amos Patrick unearthed the link to Real Live Preacher’s exposition of the scriptures mentioned below: A Look at the Bible and Homosexuality. Thanks, Amos!
Just how strong are those Bible arguments against gay marriage—and homosexuality in general—that we hear about?
It’s a critically important question. Given Jesus’ inclusion of despised people, seems like we’d want to stand on solid ground if we are to justify becoming ex-clusive.
In all the Bible, homosexuality is mentioned only six times—three in the Old Testament and three in the New. And surprisingly, all of the six comments include tough challenges for Bible students.
Real Live Preacher sketches the problem in a challenge thrown down to those who would be judgmental:
Sit down Christian. You cannot wave your unread Bible and scare me because I know the larger story that runs through it beginning to end. [...] I am your worst nightmare, a Texas preacher who knows the good book better than you do. Show me your scriptures. Show me how you justify condemning homosexual people.
Show me what you got, Christian. The Sodom story? That story is about people who wanted to commit a brutal rape. Let’s all say it together, “God doesn’t like rape”. You could have listened to your heart and learned that, Christian. Move on. What else you got?
A passage from Leviticus? Are you kidding me? Are you prepared to adhere to the whole Levitical code of behavior? No? Then why would you expect others to? Move on. What else?
Two passages – two verses from Romans and one from I Corinthians. There you stand, your justification for a worldwide campaign of hatred written on two limp pieces of paper. Have you looked closely at these passages? Do you understand their context and original language? I could show you why you don’t have much, but there is something more important you need to see.
Though few I know are involved in a “world-wide campaign of hatred,” RLP has, in a few quick strokes, revealed the dicey-ness of Bible verses often proclaimed as open-and-shut cases.
Have we done the work required to truly understand? Do we risk over-ruling the example of Jesus—and driving away millions—by interpreting a tiny set of difficult verses through cultural preference rather than Bible context?
Those are mighty high stakes. Gonna take a lot of love to work this through. What’s your thought?
Related articles by Zemanta
- Liveblog: Homosexuality sermon at Church of the Resurrection (hackingchristianity.net)